The Mill on the Floss, George Eliot, 1860
Oh, Maggie Tulliver. Mag, Mags, Magsy. Oh, Magpie. If only…. You shouldn’a…. It’s not your fault. Not like this!
In the long history of misunderstood literary youths, you are the least understood.
You just couldn’t do your gender roles, you poor, stubborn, affectionate thing.
If only your brother had your brains. If only women were allowed to exercise their mental capacities . If only your parents weren’t donkey-brained fools. They should have appreciated you, Magster. Everyone should have appreciated you.
I’m sorry Phillip pulled that friend-zone nonsense on you. I’m sorry about what went down with your cousin’s fiancé. I’m sorry your brother was such a bully. You still loved him. More than he deserved. I’m sorry Victorian society had such strange and unreasonable expectations about female sexual purity. I’m sorry everybody always assumed the worst of you.
I wish you hadn’t done the honorable thing. It caused a lot of pain for a lot of people. I know you were sticking to your principles. Couldn’t you have compromised a little? Sometimes you just have to get by in society. It doesn’t feel good, but you do what’s required sometimes. Just to avoid causing a big painful kerfuffle. You got everybody all kerfuffled. I respect you though. So much. You always did your best.
I’m especially sorry about how things ended for you. I guess you’re probably ok with…that thing that happened, but I’m not. I’m not satisfied with your ending at all.
You were worth the whole damn lot of them. That’s a reference to a book published eighty years after your book.
Nothing ever went your way.
Just know you found the perfect love you craved in the hearts of your readers even if your author wrote you a crappy ending.
Love,
Sydney
Oh I love this one. This is just how I felt about this novel. You captured it so well!
Thank you!
I felt like George Eliot gave up at the end of this one. Things were going rough for Maggie as you said, pretty much from the beginning, and then Stephen. And you just wonder, “How is she going to resolve it?” See Genesis 7.
Yes, the ending felt rushed. It only resolved one element of the story: the relationship between Maggie and her brother.